Ibarra, a Venezuelan man who entered the nation illegally, stands accused of killing the 22-year-old College of Georgia school scholar earlier this 12 months. Riley’s physique was discovered on February 22, after she did not return residence from a run.

Ibarra, 26, was arrested the next morning and charged with one depend of malice homicide, three counts of felony homicide and one depend every of kidnapping, aggravated assault, aggravated battery, hindering an emergency phone name, tampering with proof and being a peeping Tom.

He has pleaded not responsible.

The primary to take the stand on Monday was College of Georgia police officer Sgt. Joshua Epps, who testified about seeing accidents on Ibarra he mentioned “regarded like fingernail scratches” the day after the homicide.

Officers “dumpster diving” discovered a black hoodie with “lengthy, darkish hair on it” and blood stains contained in the trash bin for an residence complicated the place Ibarra lived. Safety footage confirmed a person holding onto an Adidas hat strolling as much as the dumpster and throwing one thing away; whereas looking the realm, they got here throughout Ibarra’s brother, Diego — who was sporting what seemed to be the identical Adidas hat.

Police started talking with Diego, earlier than waking up Jose and one other roommate contained in the residence to talk with them as effectively. Bodycam footage performed for the courtroom Monday confirmed officers wake the pair, telling them to return exterior.

“I observed on his proper arm, his bicep there was a scratch, which I recognized as a possible defensive wound,” mentioned Epps when requested about markings he mentioned he noticed on Ibarra. He additionally mentioned he observed what regarded like fingernail marks on his left forearm, in addition to a “puncture” he additionally thought got here from a fingernail.

“I may see like moist flesh, nearly prefer it was recent. It wasn’t very previous, presumably nonetheless irritated … I may see the liquid or physique fluids that might be in that minimize reflecting with mild.”

He additionally testified to seeing bruising to the thumb and palm space.

A second officer, Cpl. Rafael Sayan, was delivered to the scene after preliminary responders could not talk with the Ibarras, who converse Spanish. Requested in regards to the “vibe” between the brothers on the scene, Sayan mentioned, “They have been talking to 1 one other, laughing.”

“It appeared very relaxed. There was lots of laughing, laughing, particularly once they have been speaking about how they have been woken up, pulled out of the residence,” he mentioned. “I’d say the vibe or ambiance was very relaxed.”

Further bodycam footage confirmed Sayan asking Jose about redness he noticed on his knuckles. Per Sayan, Ibarra mentioned the coloring was as a result of chilly. Ibarra was additionally requested a few minimize on his proper bicep, with the suspect allegedly saying he “had a scratch however he did not precisely clarify from the place or how.”

Requested about further cuts on his arm, Ibarra at first allegedly mentioned he did not have something on them. When it was identified, he once more mentioned it was “only a scratch.” Sayan mentioned the minimize “did not look very previous.”

Police additionally had Ibarra maintain again his hair, with Sayan saying he may see “a crimson mark going throughout” his brow — “as if he had been sporting a hat.” Sayan mentioned Ibarra instructed authorities he did put on a hat just like the one Diego had on his head.

Whereas Ibarra was initially set for a jury trial, the decide agreed to a bench trial on Tuesday — that means the defendant’s destiny shall be determined by a decide and never a jury.

Prosecutor Sheila Ross, in her opening statements final Friday, mentioned Ibarra “went trying to find females on the College of Georgia campus, and on his hunt he encountered 22-year-old  Riley on her morning jog.”

“When Laken Riley refused to be his rape sufferer, he bashed her cranium in with a rock repeatedly. The proof will present that Laken fought,” she continued. “She fought for her life, she fought for her dignity, and in that struggle, she brought on this defendant to depart forensic proof behind. She additionally marked her killer for the complete world to see.”

Ross then laid out the prosecution’s timeline, utilizing digital proof gathered from safety cameras, 911 calls and Riley’s personal health watch. Per Ross, at 4:30am and 5:27am on the morning of Riley’s homicide, Ibarra shared pictures of himself to Snapchat during which he was seen sporting an Adidas hat, black jacket and hoodie (left above).

At 6:52am, a person showing to put on the identical outfit was then seen heading towards campus in safety footage (middle), the place he then tried to open one other scholar’s door whereas she showered (proper).

The prosecution mentioned this man, who they consider is Ibarra, went as much as the door six occasions within the span of an hour, attempting to open it twice. The coed inside referred to as police, reporting a Peeping Tom.

At 9:03am, Riley was seen leaving her residence on a Ring digital camera, earlier than a path cam picked her up at 9:05. That is the final time she was seen alive, headed towards the crime scene.

Then, at 9:11, mentioned Ross, Riley activated the emergency providers function on her telephone to name 911. The 1 minute, 8 second name was performed for the courtroom, during which the operator can been heard saying, “Howdy” repeatedly, earlier than asking, “Can anybody hear me?”

Solely the sounds of birds and a muffled male’s voice might be heard. When the telephone hung up, police tried calling again twice, however obtained no reply.

Riley’s physique was discovered shortly after 12:30pm that very same day, in a wooded space off the path.

“She was hidden, nearly below a tree, coated up with a bunch of leaves. Her breasts have been fully uncovered. All three layers of her clothes have been pulled up round her neck,” mentioned Ross. “Her underwear was protruding from her tights … [she had] extreme accidents to the left facet of her head. She was lifeless, she was chilly.”

Utilizing medical knowledge pulled from her Garmin watch, Ross mentioned it confirmed Riley was operating and listening to music when “one thing” all of a sudden occurred to her. “He does one thing to her, to make her cease lifeless in her tracks,” she claimed.

“Her coronary heart fee continues to be going till 9:28am. Her encounter with him was lengthy. Her struggle with him was fierce and that’s what the Garmin knowledge exhibits,” added Ross. “As soon as her coronary heart stops at 9:28am, there is no extra motion kind her Garmin.”

As police regarded for a lead, they began “dumpster diving,” mentioned Ross — with one officer discovering a black hoodie with “lengthy, darkish hair on it” and blood stains. A safety digital camera pointed on the dumpster then confirmed somebody holding an Adidas hat and sporting the identical shirt Ibarra was seen in sporting in one other Snapchat picture strolling towards the bin and dropping the jacket inside (cut up above). He was additionally seen leaving one thing within the close by bushes, which have been later discovered to be black disposable gloves with blood on them.

Whereas police continued to look the realm the next morning, they got here throughout Ibarra’s brother, Diego, sporting the identical Adidas hat. They ultimately acquired a warrant for his residence and located Jose asleep inside.

Per Ross, DNA of each Riley and Ibarra was discovered on the jacket, whereas the hair was “per Laken’s” and appeared “forcibly faraway from her head.” Ross additionally mentioned Ibarra’s DNA was left below her fingernails, whereas his thumbprint was left on her iPhone display.

Detailing the assault on Riley, Ross additionally mentioned a sexual assault package got here again unfavorable for male DNA, although her underwear had been torn. She mentioned Riley suffered a posh, depressed cranium fracture, in addition to 8 lacerations of the cranium “which accurately appear like holes,” and abrasions to the neck, face and torso.

“The proof that Jose Ibarra killed anybody is circumstantial,” Ibarra’s legal professional, Dustin W. Kirby, shared in his opening assertion on Friday. Kirby additionally claimed it will take “gymnastics” for prosecutors to show his consumer was the killer.

“We waived a jury trial on this case, with the hope and belief that regardless of the character of this proof that you might come to a verdict that was not only a means of of easing this household struggling, but it surely was primarily based on an neutral and sincere evaluation of the proof on this case,” he additionally mentioned.

“If that occurs and the presumption of innocence is revered, there shouldn’t be sufficient proof to persuade you past an inexpensive doubt that Mr. Ibarra is responsible of the crimes charged,” he added.